The 7 Deadly Sins of Casino Marketing (And How to Avoid Them)

When my career started, I never imagined I would love to be a part of an industry that moves so quickly. I imagined I would have an office with windows, create great ad campaigns like those I saw on television, take a couple of hours for lunch, have a few meetings with clients, and rinse and repeat.

Boy, was I wrong!

Sure, there are tried-and-true casino marketing methods – players club programs, promotions and data.

But what if our most comfortable strategies are leading us astray? Inspired by Tom Fishburn’s 7 Deadly Sins of Data-Driven Marketing, let’s look at how similar mistakes show up in casino marketing—and, more importantly, how we can avoid them.

Here are 7 Deadly Sins of Casino Marketing, along with a few practical first steps to avoid them.

Sin #1: Pride of Vanity Metrics

In the rush to show success, we often focus on surface-level metrics that make us feel good but don’t translate to actual business results. Metrics like player enrollments, social media engagement, or app downloads might boost our ego, but they aren’t always linked to long-term revenue or player loyalty.

Instead of focusing on vanity metrics, dig deeper. Ask yourself: How many new players are converting into regulars? How many are returning after their initial visit? The real success lies in understanding how engaged players are over time. Focus on metrics like lifetime player value, frequency of visits, and cross-property play (if applicable), which provide a more meaningful view of growth and loyalty.

Steps to Avoid the Sin of Pride:

Set measurable goals: Identify the business outcomes that matter for long-term growth, like player lifetime value or repeat visits, and focus on those metrics rather than short-term vanity ones.
Track engagement over time: Measure how many players return after their first visit and how many players interact with multiple offers, events and promotions. Set a baseline to assess long-term engagement.
Tie marketing efforts to revenue: Use player tracking systems to link your campaigns directly to spending (both in gaming and non-gaming areas) so you can see the financial impact.
Analyze player segments: Go beyond general data and examine how different segments (new players vs. regulars) engage with your offers.
Create a dashboard: Build a dashboard that tracks key performance indicators (KPIs) that reflect real growth, such as average spending per player or percentage of active players returning monthly.

The Lesson: Look beyond the numbers that feel good. Prioritize metrics that tell a more complete story about player behavior and engagement.

Sin #2: Gluttony of Mass Promotions

Sending out blanket offers to your entire database is easy, but it’s also lazy. Overloading players with offers they don’t care about can lead to “promotional fatigue,” and we miss the opportunity to connect meaningfully. Just because we can promote everything to everyone doesn’t mean we should.

Focus on programming your calendar with segmentation in mind. Use player data to understand who your high-value guests are, which types of promotions drive their behavior, and what kinds of incentives matter most to them. A targeted approach—where the right offer reaches the right player—delivers higher ROI and keeps your messaging relevant. Personalization is key to keeping players engaged without overwhelming them.

Steps to Avoid the Sin of Gluttony:

Segment your database: Use your CRM to segment your players by meaningful categories, such as ADT or loss, visitation patterns, or location.
Create player personas: Develop 4-5 detailed player personas representing your core audience segments. Use these to guide personalized marketing campaigns.
Personalize offers and engagement: Match programs to player preferences. For example, if a segment responds best to an intimate event, don’t promote a mass promotion.
A/B test promotions: Run tests to see which segmented offers perform better, then adjust your future strategies based on those insights.

Lesson: Quality over quantity. Make every program and offer count by tailoring it to specific player segments and their unique preferences.

Sin #3: Wrath of Ignoring Feedback

It’s easy to dismiss feedback that doesn’t align with our existing strategy. Whether it’s a negative review or criticism about a promotion, ignoring player input—especially when it challenges what we think we know—can damage relationships and alienate players.

Embrace feedback, both good and bad. Look at reviews, player surveys, and complaints as opportunities for improvement. Player feedback offers a window into what is working and where there is room for growth. The most successful marketers constantly refine their strategies based on this real-time input rather than stubbornly sticking to outdated approaches.

Steps to Avoid the Sin of Wrath:

Monitor all feedback channels: Monitor social media, surveys, and in-person feedback at the casino. Collect this data systematically to identify trends.
Conduct regular player surveys: Ask players for specific feedback on their experience—what they liked, what could be improved, and what they’d love to see more of.
Respond promptly: Acknowledge complaints or concerns and provide timely responses, even if the fix isn’t immediate. This shows players you care.
Analyze recurring themes: Look for patterns in feedback—whether it’s complaints about wait times, rewards structures, or promotional offers—and make adjustments based on player sentiment.
Create a player feedback loop: Regularly update players on how their feedback influences changes at your casino. Let them know you’re listening!

Lesson: Listen to your players. Let their feedback guide continuous improvement, and don’t be afraid to pivot if something isn’t working.

Sin #4: Lust for Loyalty Programs Without Emotional Connection

Casino marketers often assume that points alone are enough to keep players returning. While players club programs are essential, they are not a cure-all. Simply offering rewards will not maintain player interest over the long term.

Loyalty programs should go beyond points. Think of how you can create experiences that build emotional connections, whether that’s through personalized rewards, VIP experiences, or events that make players feel genuinely valued. Consider how you can reward not just spending but engagement: visits to the casino, event participation, and even social media activity.

Steps to Avoid the Sin of Lust:

Review your program tiers: Make sure your players club program is structured to reward spending as well as other engagement activities, such as visits, events, or social media interactions.
Offer personalized rewards: Go beyond points by sending individualized offers based on player preferences, whether that’s a special dinner, a show, or access to exclusive events.
Host regular VIP events: Plan experiences for your high-value players, like exclusive parties or meet-and-greets, to make them feel appreciated beyond the point system.
Incorporate surprise rewards: Occasionally offer unexpected bonuses or gifts to surprise and delight your players, creating emotional connections beyond transactional loyalty.
Track emotional loyalty: Use surveys and feedback to measure how emotionally connected players feel to your brand. Offer experiences that cater to these emotions, not just rewards.

Lesson: Don’t just reward transactions. Build relationships with players by offering experiences that deepen their loyalty and engagement with your brand.

Sin #5: Greed of Hoarding Knowledge in Your Departmental Silo

Hoarding data or insights within the marketing department can be tempting, especially when success is measured in isolated terms. But when data is locked away from other departments—like operations, food and beverage, or customer service—players suffer from a disjointed experience.

Encourage collaboration across departments. Share player data and insights with other teams to ensure a seamless player journey from marketing promotions to their in-person experience at the property. When marketing, operations, and customer service work together, the player experience becomes more cohesive and satisfying.

Steps to Avoid the Sin of Greed:

Create cross-departmental meetings: Regularly meet with operations, F&B, hotel, IT and customer service to discuss player insights and ensure team alignment.
Share campaign data: Inform other departments about upcoming marketing campaigns, promotions, and player trends so they can deliver a seamless experience on the casino floor.
Collaborate on promotions: Work with other departments (like events or dining) to create integrated promotions that benefit the casino and the different areas of your property.
Train staff on player segments: Ensure front-line staff understand your key player segments and how to cater to their needs. A well-informed team creates a better player experience.
Create a shared KPI dashboard: Build a dashboard that all departments can access to track key metrics related to player behavior, satisfaction, and spending.

Lesson: Break down silos. Share insights across departments to deliver a unified player experience from start to finish.

Sin #6: Envy of Others’ Campaigns, Budgets and Facilities

We sometimes fall into the trap of envying competitors’ success or the latest marketing trends, leading us to chase after flashy strategies that don’t suit our brand or players. Instead of recognizing our unique strengths, we may mimic what others are doing, ignoring the assets and advantages we already have.

Focus on what sets your casino apart and leverage those strengths. Whether it’s a unique player base, strong community ties, or specialized offerings, recognize and capitalize on what makes your casino special. Analyze your data and strengths before rushing to adopt a strategy that works for someone else. Be confident in refining and evolving your campaigns based on what works best for your players.

Steps to Avoid the Sin of Envy:

Assess your unique strengths: Identify your casino’s unique selling points and ensure your marketing highlights these assets.
Conduct a player SWOT analysis: Evaluate your players’ Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) to find what resonates most. Use this to develop campaigns that reflect your actual advantages.
Benchmark, don’t blindly copy: It’s okay to look at what competitors are doing, but always ask: Does this align with our strengths? Use benchmarking as inspiration, but build your tailored strategy.
Leverage your data: Dive deep into your player data to see what campaigns have been successful for you. Avoid chasing industry trends unless they align with your existing player base.
Create unique experiences: Instead of copying a competitor’s promotion or event, think about how you can tailor it to your casino’s unique strengths—whether through personalized rewards, exclusive experiences, or local partnerships.

Lesson: Envy can blind you to your strengths. Instead of chasing what’s trending, build campaigns around your casino’s unique brand and the data you collect from your players.

Sin #7: Sloth in Clinging to the Status Quo

It’s easy to fall back on what has always worked. Running the same promotions, tournaments, and events year after year may feel safe, but it can also lead to player fatigue and employee indifference. Without innovation, players (and employees) may lose interest and seek inspiration elsewhere.

Introduce new ideas, events, and experiences to keep your marketing fresh. Experiment with new formats, try different reward structures and bring in fresh entertainment or themes that can create excitement. Stay ahead of trends to offer something unexpected that sets your casino apart.

Steps to Avoid the Sin of Sloth:

Conduct research: Regularly review what other casinos or entertainment venues are doing to innovate. Identify new ideas that could fit with your brand and audience.
Survey players for new ideas: Ask your players directly what types of promotions, events, or rewards would excite them. Use this feedback to refresh your offerings.
Introduce seasonal events: Plan new events around holidays, local festivals, or entertainment trends to keep your offerings current and appealing.
Test new promotion formats: Try out new marketing tactics, such as gamification (e.g., app-based challenges) or influencer partnerships, to reach new audiences or engage your current base in unexpected ways.
Rotate your entertainment: Keep your entertainment lineup fresh by regularly updating shows, acts, or performances. New and exciting entertainment will give players a reason to visit more frequently.

Lesson: Don’t get lazy. Continuously innovate and offer fresh experiences to keep your players engaged and returning for more.

Turning Sins into Action

Avoiding these seven deadly sins isn’t just about recognizing the pitfalls; it’s about taking concrete steps to prevent them. Casino marketers who focus on deepening player engagement, innovating, listening to feedback, and collaborating across departments will find that they’re not only avoiding the sins but also creating stronger, longer-lasting relationships with their players. Start by following the steps above, and watch how even small changes can lead to significant improvements in your casino marketing strategy.

The key is to stay proactive, flexible, and open to change because resting on your laurels is the biggest sin.

If you’ve found us through a link, sign up for our newsletter to receive exclusive tips, insights, and industry updates. Take the first step towards casino marketing success today!